Best Store Bought Cocktail Sauce Brand. Those other blends of spices will depend on the maker. Best Store Bought Cocktail Sauce 2020 – Top 10 Rated . Seafood specialist Old Bay is another good cocktail sauce featured on this list. It isn’t necessary to refrigerate an unopened can of cocktail sauce. St. Elmo Shrimp Cocktail Sauce is another cocktail sauce derived from an American restaurant. It comes in an 8-ounce jar and is on par with the prices of Old Original Bookbinder’s cocktail sauce, but don’t let its smaller size fool you. If you plan on using it as a dip, pour the sauce into a container and serve as is, treating it as you would with any traditional cocktail sauce. Standout Features of Johnny’s French Cocktail Sauce: Best for: An affordable, award-winning cocktail sauce with a sweeter flavor. Moreover, this is the best practice for any cocktail sauce. The Best Cocktail Sauce Brands. Keep in mind that the longer a jar of cocktail sauce has been open, the more likely it will start losing its flavor over time. Old Original Bookbinder was a restaurant in Philadelphia established in 1865. Other great companies that appear on this top cocktail sauce brands list include Bookbinders, Stonewall Kitchen, and McCormick & Company. If you’re after a robust flavor with the hottest horseradish spice you’ve ever encountered from a cocktail sauce, St. Elmo is the perfect choice for you. Unopened cocktail sauce containers don’t need refrigeration, but they must be away from direct sunlight. Cocktail Sauce Dipping Cup - … The store-bought cocktail sauce just doesn't have the depth of flavor that freshly made cocktail sauce does. Delicious Dip Recipes. Lists of your favorite things to stuff in your face, ranked. Upon the request of countless customers, they launched their cocktail sauce into retail grocery stores. Therefore, it makes a perfect gift for spicy cocktail sauce lovers. Kraft is a popular company when it comes to all kinds of condiments, including cocktail sauce. The main ingredients in cocktail sauce include horseradish, ketchup, Worcestershire sauce, lemon, and Tabasco sauce. However, one must consider that it also comes bundled with St. Elmo’s delicious steak house seasoning. Old Original Bookbinder’s cocktail sauce is sold in many grocery stores across the United States, although Sam’s Club no longer carries it. Because Johnny’s French Cocktail Sauce is technically an au jus. However, the sensation goes away quickly, making it perfect for those who prefer to avoid spicier sauces. Best for: People wanting a mild to medium spice from an 1800s American restaurant. Home » By Cooking Style » 30 Minutes or Less Recipes » The Best Cocktail Sauce Ever. Therefore, you should learn what to look out for to tell if your cocktail sauce is terrible. As you’ll learn in our FAQ section, cocktail sauce’s use goes beyond shrimp and seafood. They use fresh California tomatoes ripened right on the vine. You can use cocktail sauces on fried seafood, meatloaf, oysters, fish cakes, and even chili and Bloody Mary’s. It pairs beautifully with shrimp and other seafood. Agave nectar and cane sugar offer a touch of sweetness without the use of high-fructose corn syrup. Johnny’s French Cocktail Sauce’s roots are in Seattle. Since the concentrated sauce can be diluted and used in countless ways, this little bottle will last you a long time. But … Johnny’s French Cocktail Sauce comes as a concentrated form. Published on: September 29, 2011 / Updated on April 10, 2018 Pin Share Share Email Shares 5.1k What companies will you find on this list of the best cocktail sauce brands? If your local grocer doesn’t sell it, fear not—you can order it online and have it shipped to you anywhere. And for the best cocktail-sauce experience, you really must make your own. But when it comes to cocktail sauce, it gives dishes an extra kick. Cocktail sauce is most commonly paired with shrimp, but its uses extend far beyond this for creative cooks. In case you need more convincing, Stonewall Kitchen has won 28 awards from the Specialty Food Association and three awards as an Outstanding Product Line. We spend 58 hours on researching and comparing 28 of popular models to determine the Best Store Bought Cocktail Sauce 2020 you can buy. Sharp horseradish flavor, offering lots of heat, Sold with St. Elmo’s Steak House Seasoning, Beefy flavor, making it an excellent cocktail sauce for meat, An original recipe from Johnny’s Seattle restaurant, Uses ingredients such as red wine vinegar and tomato paste, Made with fresh vine-ripened California tomatoes, Versatile enough for pairing with foods like french fries and onion rings, Mild, tomato-based flavor with a hint of horseradish, Specks of white or fuzz on the surface, showing signs of mold.